
On 13 November 2026 Hosiden announced the HVE1481, a clamp-on high-frequency current sensor covering 3–250 MHz with IPX7 sealing for outdoor substations. Within the same fortnight, two Chinese patent grants described partial-discharge monitors that fuse ultra-high-frequency (UHF) signals with acoustic or dissolved-gas channels. PD monitoring system selection is therefore no longer about which single sensor is best, but which combination of channels can see the defect you actually have.
Start from the defect, not from the sensor
Every internal discharge radiates electromagnetic energy, pressure waves and pulse currents at once, but not in the same proportion. A floating particle lights up a UHF antenna while barely exciting the tank wall; a creeping discharge is loud acoustically and weak in UHF; a turn-to-turn fault reaches a high-frequency current transformer (HFCT) but may never reach an antenna. Band figures below are vendor data.
| Defect type | Dominant quantity | Channel that sees it first | Channel likely to miss it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Floating potential / protrusion | UHF radiation, 300–1500 MHz | UHF coupler at drain valve | Acoustic, if the source is deep in the winding |
| Surface creep on pressboard | Acoustic, 80–200 kHz | AE sensor on the tank wall | UHF, when the discharge is shielded |
| Turn-to-turn fault | Pulse current in winding | HFCT on core-clamp earth | UHF, if the pulse never reaches the oil gap |
| Bushing or OLTC discharge | Mixed, path-dependent | Channel mounted at the component | Any single tank-level sensor |
Sensitivity and synchronization are specifications, not adjectives
“5 pC minimum detectable” means one thing: apparent charge measured in a defined test circuit with a defined calibrator. Apparent charge describes the measurement loop, not the defect, and does not convert honestly into the dB or millivolt figures online channels report. Two vendors quoting pC values from different circuits are comparing test benches, not instruments.
Timing follows the same rule. Time-difference location works only if the acquisition unit samples all channels together. A unit specified at 125 MS/s, 14-bit and under 100 ns channel-to-channel skew (vendor data for the TPD-400) can support location; 1 ns of timing error already maps to tens of centimetres of path error, so a device that timestamps channels separately cannot locate anything. If location matters, synchronization is a hard gate, not an upgrade.
The seven-item shortlist
With the defect list and signal chain settled, the remaining PD monitoring system selection decisions constrain each other in a fixed order.
| Decision | Quotation usually says | Question to ask | Cost if unresolved |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Channel mix | “4-in-1 multi-sensor” | Which defect does each channel cover? | A channel that never triggers |
| 2. Sensitivity basis | “5 pC” | Measured in what circuit, with what calibrator? | Cross-vendor numbers meaningless |
| 3. Synchronization | “Multi-channel” | Shared clock? What skew? | Detection without location |
| 4. Live installation | “Easy retrofit” | Which mounting points need an outage? | Hidden outage cost |
| 5. Communication | “Supports SCADA” | IEC 61850 (DL/T 860) or Modbus? | A gateway added later |
| 6. Environment | “Industrial grade” | Rating and range at the cubicle? | Derating and condensation faults |
| 7. Acceptance | “Thresholds included” | Factory threshold or self-built baseline? | False alarms, then ignored |
The last row decides whether the project survives its first season. Online PD channels report in units with no universal threshold, so a monitor is only as useful as the baseline it builds on its own transformer; factory thresholds without trending discipline get muted by operators within months, as covered in PD alarm thresholds and trending. PD also belongs beside dissolved gas analysis (DGA), not in competition with it — see PD versus DGA and the DGM-900 multi-gas monitor. For the sensing principles behind the shortlist, read detection methods compared and online PD monitoring cost.
Can one PD monitoring system cover several transformers?
Sensors cannot be shared: a UHF coupler, acoustic pad or HFCT measures the tank it is mounted on. The acquisition unit can be shared, provided every input is sampled simultaneously — once channels are multiplexed, cross-channel timing and location are gone. Two or three transformers in one station can share an IED; a fleet rollout is simpler with per-transformer units.
Is a 5 pC figure comparable across vendors?
No, unless both came from the same circuit and calibrator. A pC number is evidence about a test setup, not a ranking of instruments. The honest comparison is a controlled injection test on the same transformer, or a documented baseline band from the first weeks of operation.
PAS DGA for partial discharge monitoring
The TPD-400 combines UHF (300–1500 MHz), RF, acoustic emission (80–200 kHz) and HFCT (0.3–30 MHz) channels in one unit for 110 kV and above oil-immersed transformers, installed live at the tank, drain valve, hand-hole and core-clamp earth. It is designed to IEC TS 62478 / GB/T 42287 for non-conventional PD measurement and to IEC 61850 (DL/T 860) and DL/T 1498.1 for substation integration — a statement of method, not a type-test certificate. For a PD monitoring system selection review against your defect history, write to our engineering team.
Sources
- Hosiden HVE1481 announcement, 13 November 2026 — vendor data.
- State Grid NARI AI-based converter-transformer fault defence patent, granted 30 October 2026.
- Patent CN117872223B, UHF PD + online DGA + zero-flux current fusion, granted 30 October 2026.
- IEC TS 62478:2016; IEC 60270:2025; TPD-400 datasheet figures — vendor data.