The Duval Pentagon does with five gases what the Duval Triangle does with three: it turns a dissolved gas analysis result into a single point on a chart, and the zone that point falls in is the fault type. The triangle keeps only CH4, C2H4 and C2H2; the pentagon keeps H2 and C2H6 as well, which is why it can separate low-temperature thermal faults from stray gassing where the triangle has to lump them together.

This page does the arithmetic: it forms the five relative percentages, places each gas on its axis, draws the connecting polygon and marks its centroid. It does not name a fault zone — that last step is read off the published zone map, and section 4 explains why it is deliberately left to you.

1. Enter the five gas concentrations

Any consistent unit works as long as all five use the same one — ppm by volume is the convention in IEC 60599. Enter the values as reported by the laboratory or the monitor.

Nothing is sent anywhere — the calculation runs in your browser.

—
Enter values to plot the sample.

2. How the percentages are formed

Each gas is expressed as a share of the five-gas total, not as a share of every gas measured. The denominator is H2 + C2H6 + CH4 + C2H4 + C2H2. CO, CO2 and N2 are excluded, because the pentagon is a hydrocarbon-fault map and carbon oxides would pull every point toward the paper-fault side of the figure.

The five gases are placed around the pentagon in order of the energy needed to produce them: H2, C2H6, CH4, C2H4, C2H2. Each gas gets one axis running from the centre, which is 0%, to its vertex. A sample therefore contributes five points, one per axis; joining them gives an irregular pentagon, and its centroid is the single point the method reads. A sample with equal shares of all five gases collapses to the centre.

Why the polygon rather than a weighted average

Collapsing five numbers to one with a naive average would lose the shape of the gas profile — two very different faults can average to the same figure. Drawing the polygon keeps the profile visible: a spike toward C2H4 and a spike toward C2H2 both matter, and the centroid reflects where the mass of that shape sits rather than what the numbers sum to.

3. The zones, and what each one means

The zone boundaries themselves are published in the standards — the map below gives the fault type each zone represents, so you can read the centroid against the figure in your edition of the standard.

ZoneFault typeCharacteristic gases
PDPartial dischargesH2 dominant, very little hydrocarbon
D1Discharges of low energyH2 with C2H2
D2Discharges of high energyC2H2 with C2H4
T1Thermal fault, t < 300 °CCH4, some C2H6
T2Thermal fault, 300 °C – 700 °CC2H6 with C2H4
T3Thermal fault, t > 700 °CC2H4 dominant
SStray gassing of mineral oilLow-temperature H2 and CH4, no fault

The zones are arranged by energy: PD and D1 sit against the H2 vertex, D2 and T3 against the C2H2 and C2H4 side, and T1 against CH4. That ordering is the point of the tool — a sample moving toward the hydrocarbon corner is a sample moving toward a hotter fault.

4. Why this page does not name the zone

Because the zone map is versioned and the versions are not interchangeable. Pentagon 1, from Duval and Lamarre’s 2002 paper, uses seven regions. Pentagon 2 splits the thermal region further, separating carbonisation of paper (C) and low-temperature overheating of oil (O) from the general thermal zones, and it is the version referenced by more recent editions of the standards. A tool that hard-codes one edition’s polygons will quietly mislabel a sample the day the reader’s laboratory switches editions — and a wrong fault type on a transformer is not a cosmetic error.

So this page stops at the point the method actually computes: the relative percentages and the centroid. Read the centroid against the zone map printed in your edition of IEC 60599 or IEEE C57.104, and treat the answer as an input to diagnosis rather than the diagnosis itself.

5. Reading the result responsibly

  • A point near a boundary is not a result. Near an edge, measurement uncertainty decides the zone, not the method. Say so in the report.
  • Trend beats a single sample. Two consecutive samples moving in one direction are stronger evidence than one sample sitting deep inside a zone.
  • Tiny denominators are meaningless. If the five-gas total is only a few ppm, the percentages are unstable and the centroid is noise.
  • Check the units. A ppm value entered next to a percentage value produces a plausible-looking, entirely wrong figure.

6. Frequently asked questions

What units should I enter?

Any unit, as long as all five gases use the same one. The calculation is on relative proportions, so ppm, µL/L and ppb all give the same percentages and the same centroid. Do not mix a ppm value with a percentage value.

What if one gas is below the detection limit?

Enter zero. A concentration below the limit of detection is correctly treated as a zero share. Be aware that this pushes the centroid toward the remaining gases, so the result is weaker evidence than a full five-gas analysis.

Why is CO and CO2 excluded?

The pentagon is built on the five hydrocarbon gases. Carbon oxides indicate paper involvement, but they are not part of the fault-type map; a fault in paper is identified from the CO2/CO ratio and from furans, which is a separate assessment.

Can I use this for ester or silicone oils?

No. The pentagon zones were derived for mineral oil. Duval Triangles 3, 6 and 7 exist for vegetable and silicone oils, and the pentagon zone boundaries should not be transferred to them.

Does the pentagon replace the triangle?

No. Use the triangle when only CH4, C2H4 and C2H2 are available — many hydrogen-only or three-gas monitors cannot supply more. Use the pentagon when all five hydrocarbons are available and the fault sits in the thermal range, because that is where dropping H2 and C2H6 costs resolution.

7. Where to go next